Previously on Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Buffy put Faith in a coma for 8 months prior to the Mayor's Ascension, but the rogue Slayer awakes and goes after Buffy, swapping bodies with her. The Scoobies have steadily been growing apart over the course of the season and fractures are getting worse.
Picking up directly after This Year's Girl, Faith finds herself trying to get used to Buffy's world and her body, picking up on the events that she's missed and the people she hasn't met yet (Anya, Spike). She takes advantage of her new freedom and the trust that everyone has placed in Buffy to get on and do what she wants for a bit. Meanwhile, Buffy is trapped inside Faith's body, dragged away first by the cops and then by the agents from the Watchers' Council, unable to convince anyone of who she says she is. As Faith has to get accustomed to being the good guy for a change and the effect it has on her, Buffy finds life on the other side difficult, fighting her way back to her own body.
Who Are You marks the halfway point of Buffy the Vampire Slayer and the turning point for Faith as she realises that she might need saving after all. It's an extremely clever way of doing it. Much of Faith's resentment towards Buffy is borne out of the things that our Miss Summers is surrounded with - friends, family, people who love and respect her - people that Faith has never had in her life and didn't know how to accept when it was offered to her. It's key that Faith's big freak-out comes after Riley tells her, believing her to be Buffy, that he loves her. He doesn't mistreat her, he doesn't use her, he simply wants to be with her.
After that moment, Faith starts to see redemption as something she might want after all. That saving people and doing the right thing might be the path she wants to go down. Sarah Michelle Gellar's performance is a fantastic one, asked to perform a character that is so completely different to Buffy and to convey one of the character's most important moments within that. The climactic fight between Faith and Buffy brings out all of Faith's self-loathing, something which will be explored more once she appears in Angel soon. It's interesting though that once they've switched back, Buffy doesn't seem to have learnt anything from her time as Faith. She still sees her as a criminal who needs to be dealt with rather than someone who needs to be understood and helped. Maybe Faith has a point about that stick up her butt after all...
On the opposite side, Eliza Dushku gets to play the hero and does so with aplomb, capturing Gellar's mannerisms with ease, ensuring you never forget which one of them you're watching at any moment in time. Gellar may seemingly have the harder job, but it's Dushku on whom the episode's success relies. Her line delivery all the way through as Buffy is brilliant, particularly her scene in which she tries to convince Giles of who she is. The way she says "you were inching!" is perfect. Even the eyebrow movements are recognisably Buffy's.
There are interesting little moments in here about Tara's future role in the group, confirming her relationship with Willow for a start, but also, she's the first person to notice that Buffy, as Willow believes her to be, is not herself, something which the Scoobies miss. Later on, Tara and Buffy would go on to develop quite a close relationship, partly due to Tara's perceptiveness and Buffy's willingness to trust her. It's a good measure of just how fractured the Scoobies are at this stage in the season. None of them notice Buffy's exceedingly odd behaviour until it's pointed out to them in no uncertain terms. Tara proves to be the key to the episode, an essential component in the gang who they don't realise they need just yet.
But the episode belongs to Faith, a deeply fascinating character and one who undergoes one of the biggest arcs, probably behind only Spike's and Willow's respective stories over the course of the show. Bringing her back, positioning her once again in opposition to Buffy, but with considerably more sympathy, is a genius move, another soaring high point in the ridiculously mixed fourth season.
We've still got a bit to go, but hey, have you heard about this amazing Jonathan guy? He's a superstar.
Quote of the Week:
Faith: You're not going to kill these people.
Vamp: Why not?
Faith: Because it's wrong.
Let's Get Trivial: The expiration date of Joyce's credit card, glimpsed briefly, is May 2001, the month in which Buffy will die for the second time.
Sunnydale Who's Who: The credits list "Eliza Dushku as Buffy" this time around.
- Becky
You can read Becky's look at previous episode, This Year's Girl, here.
Follow @AssortedBuffery on Twitter
Or like our Facebook page
Previously on Buffy the Vampire Slayer: When Kendra was killed by Drusilla, Faith was called, a Slayer from Boston with some mental health issues and a passion for turning to the dark side. Buffy put her in a coma before the big fight with the Mayor and there she's remained. The Initiative is crumbling with Adam on the loose and Riley's hospitalised.
Buffy is still reeling from Riley being taken away from her and Adam running loose around Sunnydale, dissecting demons and generally being a bit horrible. However, a more immediate problem is on the way. Faith, in a hospital since her scrap with Buffy before Graduation Day, has woken up and has escaped. The rogue Slayer is on the move and after Buffy, reeling from finding out that not only has she been in a coma for eight months, but Graduation Day has failed and Buffy succeeded in killing the Mayor. She goes after our little Buffster with a neat weapon the Mayor managed to leave her.
After the considerable awfulness that has been the last two episodes, I've been so looking forward to getting to the Faith episodes because a) they have a real classic Buffy feel about them and b) Eliza Dushku is awesome in this role. She slips back into it fast, a riot of pent-up energy and rage that's directed in the Scoobies' direction. Her first scene with Sarah Michelle Gellar also snaps back into the antagonistic relationship their characters' share with their quips and begrudging respect for each other. It's amazing how quickly the Initiative stuff falls away once she arrives and the quality of the season once again soars. Plus, Joyce comes back!
Kristine Sutherland's absence has been notable from this season, a voice of reason to counter Giles and the others with wit and style. Donald Petrie's script acknowledges this by having Faith use it to get to Joyce, mocking her with hypotheses that Buffy has forgotten them both because she's so damn selfish. Of course, Joyce gives as good as she gets and takes the piss out of Faith with glee. Glorious. I do feel a little sorry for the 1630 Revello Drive though; it's been months since it had to have any repairs done to it. It must have been so peaceful. Poor house.
An interesting element of the episode, amongst others, is seeing into Faith's dreams. Buffy's prophetic dreaming crops up as needed, but This Year's Girl allows us to see into another Slayer's psyche and it's Faith's so it's twisted. Obviously. It positions Buffy as the bad guy, a Terminator-like presence determined to ruin her life. It's a swift way of reacquainting us with their antagonistic relationship, as well as clueing us in to the eventual topsy-turvy nature of the follow-up episode, Who Are You.
Christophe Beck's ethereal score in the sequences are truly amazing, especially the horror-esque vocal refrain that haunt Faith as she's being chased by Buffy. It gives the dreams an even more wacky quality, removed from the rest of the episode but highly important for what's to come. Hello, Dawn foreshadowing; it's the second reference we get from Faith about her after the Little Miss Muffet line in Graduation Day Part 2. He's a canny bugger, is that Whedon.
Most of all though, and it's something the worst episodes of the fourth season are missing, is that it's so damn entertaining. Dushku seizes her return with gusto and reminds everyone why we all love to hate Faith in these pre-redemption and her fights with Buffy are scrappy and dramatic. Those fights are also ones for the longterm fans; we know how good both of them are so there's no pauses, no need for orchestrated dynamic shifting. It's just two skilled fighters going at it and you're never quite sure which one is going to come out on top in each one.
This Year's Girl is the first of a two-parter and ends on one heck of a cliffhanger. I remember watching that for the first time, hearing "five by five," realising what happened and then being ridiculously angry that I need to wait another week for the resolution. Fortunately, the power is in my hands to watch it right now. You guys have to wait another week for what I think of it, but I'm sure not many of you are particularly angry about that.
Five by five.
Quote of the Week:
Giles: Well, we have to find [Faith].
Willow: What about Adam?
Xander: I'd hate to see the pursuit of a homicidal lunatic get in the way of pursuing a homicidal lunatic.
Inventive Kill: Adam, unseen for the episode, dissects a demon and leaves it hanging between trees for the Scoobs to find. Lovely.
Let's Get Trivial: The shop where Faith stops to admire the knives in the window is the same shop that she and Buffy broke into back in Bad Girls.
- Becky
You can read Becky's look at previous episode, Goodbye Iowa, here.
Follow @AssortedBuffery on Twitter
Or like our Facebook page
